Murray returned to The Avenue Stadium in the summer of 2025, having first featured for the club in 2018. The technically gifted midfielder came through the Academy of Leeds United, before signing for neighbours Bradford City. He signed for York City in 2013, before going on to feature for club's such as Scarborough United, FC United of Manchester and Stalybridge Celtic in the Northern Premier League. Murray moved to Dorset in 2018, joining the Magpies for his first spell. Murray stood out in a struggling team and his energetic and creative displays soon caught the attention of local rivals Weymouth. Murray made the move over the Ridgeway, where he played a significant part in their back-to-back promotions to the National League. A change of manager saw Murray team up with Tommy Killick at Poole, joining on loan initially in 2022 before making the move permentent the following season. Killick's departure saw Murray move to Southern Premier League side Gosport Borough last season, before re-joining The Magpies the following summer.