A versatile left-sided defender who is also comfortable further forward on the wing, Hutchinson signed for the club in June 2023 from Poole Town. Hutchinson was a regular in the Dolphins side for a couple of seasons before making the switch to link up with boss Tom Killick again, while also previously impressing during his time whilst at neighbours Portland United. Son of former Magpie Ian Hutchinson, he also spent a month at fellow Southern League Premier South side Winchester City last campaign before returning to The Avenue and becoming a regular in the Magpies side.